Skip to content
Technology

Original Vice President of 360 was arrested and the real liquidation began

圖片

On the morning of November 17, the news that the vice president of 360 was taken away by the police exploded in the technology circle.

At noon, 360 Group officially confirmed that Bu Sinan, the group’s vice president and head of the marketing department, was suspected of economic problems and was discovered and reported by the company’s internal audit. He is currently under investigation by relevant departments.

圖片

This is not the first time 360 ​​has arrested executives.

Seven years ago, Huang Jing, senior director of 360 Intellectual Property Department, was arrested for taking bribes. Zhou Hongyi posted harsh words on WeChat Moments late at night: “Use the sharpest knife to cut off this rotten meat. I don’t care what kind of birdman you are.”

Only this time, the knife fell faster and at a more central location.

1. 老臣落馬

After all, Bu Sinan is a veteran of 360. He joined the company in 2014 and has been working for more than ten years.

In his public resume, he was responsible for market strategy and brand ecology in the early days, and later took charge of the ISC Internet Security Conference. ISC is positioned externally as a high-profile global security summit in the Asia-Pacific region. It is known as the vane of China’s network security industry. The conference projects are huge and the budget scale is conceivable.

In addition, he also serves as the general manager of the Education Division, leading the national information security industry-education integration community, connecting hundreds of colleges and universities, and mastering relevant national-level industry-education project resources.

The real leap occurred in August this year. In order to promote the “security + AI” strategy, 360 split the marketing and communication center into two. Bu Sinan became the head of the group’s marketing department, reporting directly to Zhou Hongyi.

From the vice president of the business line to the number one position in the core department of the group, this step is taken to become a veritable senior management echelon. But he didn’t expect that he had only stood on this level for three months.

At present, the official has not disclosed the specific amount involved and the details of the case. Many media quoted sources as saying that the case may point to job embezzlement and corruption, and the amount involved is relatively large.

Anyone who is familiar with the operation of Internet companies knows that the position of the head of the marketing department holds a real money budget in his hands. There is room for manipulation in media placement, event execution, supplier selection, and brand cooperation.

Especially for industry-level conferences like ISC, the annual budget can easily exceed tens of millions, and the chain of venues, construction, guests, communication, and suppliers is long, and the effects are difficult to accurately quantify. Naturally, it is a high-risk area for fraud.

Bu Sinan has been deeply involved in ISC for many years, and then lost his position as the head of the group’s marketing department. The extent of his involvement will probably be the real thing to watch next.

2. 戰前整肅

The timing of this anti-corruption campaign is actually worth pondering.

In August this year, we separated public relations and marketing, allowing the marketing department to report directly to the CEO. This essentially meant concentrating resources on the tough battle of AI transformation.

As a result, just three months after the new strategy was launched, the person holding the flag fell first. It is hard not to think that Zhou Hongyi took advantage of the internal audit to clean up the team before strategic transformation.

After all, the biggest fear in any company-level change is to put down resources and feed your own small circle first. Such a team cannot fight a tough battle.

Anyone familiar with 360 knows that Zhou Hongyi is a notoriously ruthless person.

In 2019, Huang Jing, senior director of 360 Intellectual Property Department, was arrested for accepting bribes from agents. Zhou Hongyi posted on WeChat Moments late at night with a picture of several tactical knives and wrote: “Some departments in the company have gained power and instead of serving users and customers, they have become rent-seeking tools. This is completely contrary to the company’s basic values ​​and culture. Use the sharpest knife to cut off these rotten meat. I don’t care what kind of birdman you are.”

At that time, the industry was in an uproar, and this time it was the genuine vice president of the group who was taken away.

What is even more intriguing is that the case was not triggered by an external report, but was reported after the company’s internal audit took the initiative to discover it. From establishing the Supervision Department in 2011, to investigating and punishing the director in 2019, to taking down the vice president in 2026, Zhou Hongyi’s anti-corruption sword has been wielded higher every time.

The signal significance of this incident is far greater than the case itself. He wants to tell the whole company: AI transformation is a life and death battle for 360. Anyone who reaches out at this juncture will be killed regardless of their seniority or position.

For companies like 360, security business is the fundamentals and AI is the ticket to the future. At the juncture of the transition between old and new kinetic energy, the health of the internal body directly determines whether the transformation can be successful.

From this perspective, Bu Sinan’s dismissal is more like a pre-war purge.

3. 反腐風暴

360 Vice President is not an exception.

Just in July this year, 11 people from NetEase Games were put on trial for corruption, including Xiang Lang, the former general manager of the marketing department. The amount involved in the case was rumored to be over 100 million.

Earlier, corruption cases were exposed one after another, including the marketing director of Meituan, the former executive of Ele.me, and the head of Kuaishou operations. In almost every round of anti-corruption storms in major companies, the market, procurement, operations, and channels are the hardest hit areas.

The reason is simple: power is concentrated, supervision is weak, and effects are vague.

I have seen too many gray operations in the marketing procurement chain. To put it bluntly, there are only three things:

The first is the waistcoat bidding.

On the surface, three or four suppliers compare bids, but in fact they are controlled by the same group of people behind the scenes, and the projects are directed to stakeholders through formality.

The second is inflated costs.

An event is quoted at one million, but the actual cost may be only three to four hundred thousand, and the price difference flows back to insiders through various names.

The third is rebates.

Rebates for media placement and advertising agencies are unspoken rules in the industry. When it comes to companies with loose supervision, the money goes directly into personal pockets.

The reason is that it is difficult to accurately calculate the effects of marketing. Sales volume can be faked, exposure can boost sales, and publicity can buy charts. As long as no one takes a closer look, whether the money spent is worth it or not depends entirely on the person in charge.

During the period of rapid growth, no one would take this seriously. The company’s annual revenue is tens of billions, and its market budget is more than one billion. As long as the market is rising and internal leaks occur, the management often turns a blind eye. After all, compared with grabbing the market and grabbing users, this “loss” is nothing.

But once the industry enters the stock period, everything changes.

When outward expansion fails, digging inward for efficiency becomes the only option. We have been clamoring for cost reduction and efficiency improvement for so many years, but it is not just the number of employees that has been reduced, but also water in the supply chain, problems in the budget, and bugs in the system.

To put it bluntly, in the past, there was money everywhere on the ground, and no one bent down to pick up the steel in the cracks; now that the money on the ground has been picked up, it is natural to start clearing the shortfall in the accounting room.

4. 合規進化

However, I always believe that when it comes to anti-corruption, arresting people is only a temporary solution, while the system is the root solution.

Looking back on the past few years, the anti-corruption efforts of major Internet companies are not unscrupulous. They have used all possible means including expulsion, transfer to the judiciary, industry blacklists, and penalty options. However, corruption cases are still emerging one after another, and the methods are becoming more and more hidden, and the amounts involved are getting larger and larger.

The fundamental problem still lies in the power structure.

Internet companies generally implement flat management, with short decision-making chains, and a large amount of resource allocation rights are delegated to the middle or even grassroots levels. A marketing director may hold an annual budget of several hundred million, and an operations director may determine the life or death of hundreds of service providers. With power so concentrated and supervision unable to keep up, it would be strange if no problems arise.

However, we have seen some changes in recent years. More and more companies are embedding compliance into business processes rather than just doing post-audits.

For example, ByteDance has built a big data risk control monitoring system that will continuously scan supplier and cost data. For signals such as an unusually high bid-winning rate for a certain type of supplier and a significant deviation from the reasonable range of marketing expense ROI, the system will automatically trigger a risk warning and submit it to the compliance team for follow-up and verification.

Another example is the formation of an industry co-governance mechanism. Hundreds of companies have joined the Sunshine Integrity Alliance, which shares information about serious disciplinary violations within the alliance. Once they are included in the list of dishonest people, they will be restricted from employment when applying for jobs at alliance member companies, which greatly increases the opportunity cost of corruption.

But these are far from enough. Real governance needs to start from the source of power, make the rules of resource allocation transparent, decentralize the approval process, and make the effect evaluation third-party.

As long as power is no longer a black box, the space for rent-seeking will naturally shrink.

5. 寫在最後

Finally, a few words of judgment.

First, this will not be the last anti-corruption case of 360 this year.

When something goes wrong in the market line, it often affects the entire market. Suppliers, downstream partners, and internal related positions can pull out a string of people along one line. The sentence “under investigation by relevant departments” in the official notification is usually just the beginning.

Second, this round of anti-corruption in major factories is far from over.

The general background of the industry moving from incremental to existing has not changed, and the main theme of cost reduction and efficiency improvement has not changed. Anti-corruption will change from a campaign to a normal one. In the next two to three years, we will see more senior executives and more veterans fired. This is not because the industry has become bad, but because the industry is paying for the extensive growth of the past two decades.

Third, for all working people, an era is truly over.

The good old days of “following the business and making some profit along the way” are gone forever. The next competition is not about who is bolder or has more resources, but who can make clean money within the tightened rules.

This isn’t a bad thing.

A truly mature business world should lose its recklessness and establish clear rules and bottom lines.

About Us · 關於我們