Skip to content
Technology

Who is fooling ordinary people into joining AI comics?

Text | Herald of Entertainment

Please, stop praising AI comics.

I don’t know if you’ve noticed that recently, hot searches about how popular and profitable AI comics are, and how they can crush live-action dramas, appear from time to time. When you click on it, you will often get a lot of praise for AI comics: some people have obtained hundreds of millions of views with one work, some have exceeded one million in revenue with AI comics, and some have achieved financial freedom in just a few months.

Counterattack stories continue to appear one after another, as if ordinary people can have the opportunity to change their destiny by seizing this opportunity.

Accompanying these success stories are more and more advertisements for AI comic training and franchises. From getting started with zero basics to quickly receiving orders, from low-cost entrepreneurship to stable income, various institutions are sending a signal to ordinary people: now is the time to enter the market.

But is this really the case? Can ordinary people really get a share of the AI ​​comic drama? Who is constantly selling them such wealth opportunities?

01 Everyone can get a piece of the pie?

For ordinary people who want to get involved in AI comics, there is a basin of cold water that must be poured on: the current market for AI comics is hot, but it does not mean that you can make money by just lying down, nor does it mean that everyone can get a piece of the pie.

Let’s look at the overall market performance first. According to data from the DataEye Research Institute, in the first half of this year, 221,900 new AI dramas and comics were added to Douyin, of which only 1,055 had more than 100 million views, accounting for about 0.48%. If the 50 million views set by DataEye are used as the break-even reference line, there are only 2,886 works that reach this scale, accounting for about 1.3%. While a large number of works are flooding into the market, there are still only a few that can actually make back their money.

As for actual income, which the public is most concerned about, the situation is also not optimistic.

According to feedback from practitioners, since this year, the revenue from AI comic dramas has been declining rapidly. The person in charge of an AI comic company revealed in an interview with China News Weekly that previously a work with over 100 million views earned more than 100 yuan in revenue per 10,000 views; but by May this year, the figure had dropped to 30 to 50 yuan. Now half a year has passed and the situation is even more grim.

If it falls to individual creators, the actual income may be even lower. The creator Shinyo once shared her experience of creating an AI comic series on Xiaohongshu: “I Became My Father’s Strongest Mouth Substitute”, which she independently produced, has 12 episodes in total and cost 1,715 yuan to produce. One month after its launch, the popularity reached 14.85 million. The actual number of views exceeded 49,000, but the income was only 19.64 yuan, and the income from 10,000 views was only 3.97 yuan. It can be seen that for individual creators who lack funds and experience, it is not easy to recover the cost from one work.

Even if the problem of work production is solved, traffic acquisition is still an unavoidable problem.

Recently, Fu Peng, an economist at Xinhuo Group, publicly pointed out that almost all AI comics have suffered losses in the past three months. According to his estimation, if you choose to invest on your own, the purchase cost will account for about 80% to 90% of the total cost, and the computing power cost will account for about 10%. Coupled with hardware depreciation, the final profit of the project will only be about 5%.

He even compared creators to “digital tenant farmers” who work for the platform, saying that AI as a new productivity has greatly improved the efficiency of content production, but it has not changed the old logic of platform bidding distribution and profit distribution. The cost saved on the production side is quickly swallowed up by traffic purchases. The higher the production efficiency, the smaller the return per unit of content is.

Of course, the high investment costs mentioned by Fu Peng mainly correspond to the business model that requires oneself to bear the purchase costs, and are not fully applicable to the distribution system of platforms such as Tomato. Take Tomato’s Changdu content distribution platform as an example. After obtaining IP authorization, creators only need to deliver the finished film. Distributors independently select products, pay for distribution, and rely on distribution conversion to get a share.

But this does not mean that producers can completely get rid of the uncertainty of traffic and income. Whether the work can obtain platform resources, how much traffic it can get after going online, and how much revenue it can ultimately share are still affected by content quality, platform project screening, traffic distribution and account sharing rules.

Taking the copyright investment model as an example, the platform will rate projects based on the script outline, character designs, plans and demos submitted by the production team. High-quality IP will only be targeted and open to a few leading producers. The “Fruit Burning Plan” previously launched by Hongguo has set up a clear project screening mechanism. In terms of AI script cooperation, Hongguo has also set different minimum guarantee policies based on content ratings. According to the latest policy announced on November 12, the minimum guarantee for S-level AI scripts is 15,000 yuan, there is no guarantee for A-level scripts, and no cooperation is allowed for B-level scripts.

Therefore, whether the work itself can be used is also a hard threshold. There are differences in the share ratios for works of different quality. For high-quality dramas with better scenes and more investment in production, the income from 10,000 broadcasts can be several times or even more than that of ordinary sinking works.

Recently, brother Xiao Guo, the creator of the hit short drama “Anhui Little Carpenter”, had a conversation with media personality Pan Luan, which also confirmed this point. For example, he said that the income from 10,000 views of a sinking drama he produced is only 1.5 yuan, while the premium drama can reach 12 yuan, a difference of 8 times. This also shows that even if the work of the same person enters the same platform and adopts similar distribution methods, the revenue performance may be very different.

As for the question of whether ordinary people should join the trap, he also gave specific suggestions: People with experience in shooting, editing, self-media or novel tweeting can try it on a small scale, while people with no relevant experience at all should not blindly participate.

This view also coincides with the view of Zhang Hansheng, the chief planner of “Armed into the Song Dynasty”. In his view, AI equality means equal opportunities to use models. Lowering the technical threshold does not mean that the creative threshold will also disappear. If you want to make better works, the key still lies in content and creative ideas. Because “AI itself has no emotions, many feelings, feelings, and emotions about family and country need to be given by the creator.” He also reminded not to package AI comics as a business where everyone can make money just by signing up for a class.

After all, the pie in the sky that ordinary people see is actually not that simple.

Recently, Xiao Tianle, a junior at Soochow University, has become a hot topic with his story of earning more than 3 million yuan from an AI comic series. However, if you take a closer look at his entrepreneurial experience, you will find that behind this achievement is the accumulation of continuous content production and commercial business. In less than a year, his team has produced hundreds of comics, among which there is only one real hit. In addition, his team also undertakes commercial orders for comic series, and the income does not simply come from platform sharing.

In a word, AI tools have indeed lowered the entry barrier, but they have not made it easier to make money. From work competition to traffic acquisition to content creation, ordinary people still have a long way to go if they want to truly reap rewards from this track.

02 Who is deceiving ordinary people into joining the game?

So, since AI comics are not a guaranteed profit-making business, who is constantly attracting ordinary people to join the business?

The people who value this business the most are obviously training institutions. I believe everyone has seen AI comic training advertisements on social platforms or short video platforms. From introductory courses worth 9.9 yuan to systematic training worth thousands or even tens of thousands of yuan, the promotional techniques are often very similar: you can learn it with zero foundation, master the production process in three days, and receive orders in a week to monetize. No professional team or film and television experience is required.

But in fact, learning the basic operations of AI tools and having the ability to produce independently are two different things. From producing pictures and videos to script adaptation and lens design, it all requires long-term practice and trial and error. Short-term training may teach students some basic operations, but it is difficult to ensure that they can complete works independently, let alone make money by accepting orders. Many people buy these AI courses and end up paying an IQ tax on themselves.

Secondly, it is investment promotion and system service providers. Compared with selling courses, this type of organization goes a step further and directly packages AI comics into a business that can be franchised: purchase a production system, pay a franchise fee, and cooperate with so-called platform resources and stable orders, you can have your own AI comic studio.

According to Entertainment News, a consumer in Hubei was charged 59,800 yuan by an Internet company in Jinan in the name of a “regional agent” to purchase an AI comic production system. The other party promised that you can learn the operation in half an hour, and you can also get a share by developing lower-level agents. But after signing the contract, he discovered that the so-called independent research and development system was actually only a public resource on the Internet, and the promised regional exclusive agent could not be fulfilled.

For these institutions, what is really important is to sell the production system, franchise qualifications and computing power packages.

In addition, there are related MCN and project intermediaries. The production of AI comics requires a lot of manpower, and some companies will recruit individual creators and small studios to take orders. There is no problem with normal project cooperation, but there are also intermediaries that recruit creators under the guise of platform orders, guaranteed profits, and internal resources, and then charge computing fees and deposits, or transfer production costs and rework risks to individuals through layers of subcontracting. For inexperienced creators, even if they get an order, they may find that the income is not enough to cover the production costs.

In addition to these business models, there is also push from platforms, tool manufacturers and industries. The platform needs more content, tool manufacturers hope to expand the use of models and computing power, production companies need production capacity, and local governments are also promoting the implementation of related industries. These factors have jointly increased the popularity of the industry and given AI comics new growth prospects.

When these real industry opportunities are packaged in layers, they eventually become a simpler and more attractive story: Entering the AI ​​comic drama now is to seize the next opportunity for wealth.

From this perspective, the path that AI comic dramas are taking is exactly the same as the live-action short dramas of the past.

Early live-action short dramas attracted a large number of teams due to their short production cycle, low cost and quick return. However, as market supply increases, it is difficult to form a competitive advantage simply by relying on low cost and mass production. Content quality and traffic acquisition have gradually become important factors in determining the performance of works. The same is true for AI comics. Technological advancements have significantly reduced the production cost of a work, allowing more individuals and teams to enter the market at the same time, and content supply has rapidly increased.

It can be seen that what AI comics are experiencing is not just a period of technological dividends, but a process from low-threshold production to fierce market competition. As the production cost advantage is gradually diluted, creators must eventually return to the content itself and solve the problems of traffic acquisition and commercial monetization.

Of course, AI comics are also moving from extensive development in the early days to standardized development.

On July 31, the State Administration of Radio and Television issued the “Measures for the Development and Management of Micro-Short Dramas”, which clarified that micro-short dramas generated and produced using AI technology should add reminder signs in accordance with regulations. On November 6, the State Administration of Radio, Film and Television deployed a new round of special management of micro-short dramas to address issues such as the uneven quality of AI micro-short dramas, vulgarity, homogeneity, and theft of faces and voices.

A controversial detail appears in “Armed into the Song Dynasty”. Some viewers discovered that starting from the third season, the original names of historical regimes such as the Northern Song Dynasty, Xixia, Liao, and Jin in the play were changed to “Southern Territory” (Northern Song Dynasty), “Western Territory” (Western Xia Dynasty), “Northern Territory” (Liao Dynasty), and “Eastern Territory” (Jin Dynasty). The names of some cities have also changed. The time-travel story that originally told the history of the Northern Song Dynasty suddenly became more like a fictional fantasy drama. Many viewers even joked that it was going to be turned into “Game of Thrones”.

Although the main creator did not publicly explain the specific reasons for the name change, chief planner Zhang Hansheng said in an interview that the team needs to consider red lines when creating and try to adapt while respecting the original work. For AI comic creators, in addition to production and market competition, content compliance is also an issue that must be considered in advance.

Industry development requires confidence and the participation of more people. But what is truly alarming is that some people only show low costs and high returns to ordinary people, but deliberately downplay market competition, business risks and compliance responsibilities, making them mistakenly believe that as long as they learn how to make, they can easily get industry dividends, and end up spending money in vain. This is somewhat unethical.

About Us · 關於我們