▲The promotional content of Black Toothpaste (Haolai Toothpaste). Picture/Cover News
On November 12, according to a cover news report, some consumers reported that Black Toothpaste (now renamed “Haolai Toothpaste”) may have exaggerated and false propaganda on the e-commerce platform.
“Reverse 18-year-old dark yellow in 3 days”, “Whiten 6.95 degrees in 3 days”, “Can break down 760% of intravasated tooth stains”… A series of eye-catching slogans, coupled with the authoritative certification “Approved by Nobel Laureate Randy Schekman”, are really eye-catching. However, how much of these seemingly alluring promotions actually stand up to scrutiny?
Frankly speaking, such advertising slogans as “the pioneer of blue light whitening, recognized by Nobel Prize professors” are indeed quite confusing. However, customer service at the brand’s flagship store said that Randy Schekman recognized the technical principles of product use and did not promise product effects.
In reality, this kind of “playing word games with consumers” will inevitably mislead them quite clearly. Moreover, Randy Schekman’s cooperative agent stated that the licensing cooperation between the two parties was terminated last year. Against this background, why are related promotional pages still using his likeness and title? Is this side-stepping practice really legal and compliant?
At the same time, data such as “disintegrating 760% of intraosmotic tooth stains” and “isolating 299% of new tooth stains” seem to be very accurate, but as many netizens have asked: What are these data that deviate from the public’s daily life knowledge as a reference, and how are they calculated?
Customer service explained that the relevant data is laboratory data compared with ordinary whitening toothpaste, and the actual effect varies from person to person. Although the comparison of indicators under laboratory conditions is not directly equivalent to the actual effect, since merchants choose to use specific numbers to attract consumers, they have the responsibility to clarify more specific data sources and experimental conditions, rather than just showing good-looking data but being vague about the details behind it.
What is even more ridiculous is that on the relevant live broadcast interface, the merchant declared in bold letters that “reversing 18 years of dark yellow in 3 days”, while also using small words to note that “it is not a one-swipe white” and “not a promise of actual results”. The former is busy raising expectations, while the latter is eager to abdicate responsibility. Since when does buying a toothpaste have to test the consumer’s observation skills?
Advertising is not about hide-and-seek. You cannot put eye-catching exaggerated promises in a prominent position and then hide the disclaimer in an inconspicuous corner. If you just want to rely on exaggerated publicity to gain traffic and boost sales, but are unwilling to take responsibility for the content of the publicity, such an abacus will obviously not work. Of course, product promotion can highlight selling points, but it cannot be pieced together and packaged into a set of marketing copy that looks authoritative but lacks sufficient explanation.
It is worth noting that when reporters asked about promotional data, the customer service of the flagship store said that there was no relevant data and it was recommended to consult the manufacturer; the official customer service of Haolai Chemical responded that the relevant flagship store is operated by authorized dealers and is not directly operated by the manufacturer.
What consumers see is the same brand, the same product and the same set of promotional pages, but there is a separation of information between the sales end and the brand side. When the live broadcast room moved the data to attract traffic, they were conclusive, but when they asked about the source and practicality of the data, they could only blame each other? For this, both dealers and brands are obviously to blame.
As the main body of product sales, dealers should provide the basis for the promotional content they publish; brand owners cannot stay out of the matter just because the store is promoted by dealers. They should also assume management responsibilities for the publicity management, product information and use of brand image of authorized dealers. After all, authorized sales cannot only involve sharing of benefits, and blaming each other for problems.
Related Reading
- Depth丨The outcast Huang Renxun, and the trillion-dollar Nvidia that has lost its helmsman2026-11-15
- Original: Wang Jianlin, 72, re-appointed as chairman of Wanda2026-11-15
- The former chairman voluntarily surrendered! With three changes of leadership in four years, how many question marks does Xiamen Bank hide?2026-11-15
- Behind the U.S. grounding: the air traffic control system has been in service for 50 years, and spare parts rely on overseas purchases2026-11-15
- Hesai, Shenghong, and Nvidia reveal the “pricing system” of technology tycoons’ extramarital affairs2026-11-14