Skip to content
Business

Original Fang Taozi, who never collapsed, failed in her first order because of “opening her eyes and telling lies”

A virtual person with no eyeballs or cornea, and even the action of “blinking” is just a code simulation, said to the camera, “I have been wearing my contact lenses for a day and they are very comfortable.” The irony of this incident is extremely high. When Fang Taozi debuted, the most resounding label was “never collapse”, but as a result, the first commercial order collapsed because of its capabilities that it did not have at all.

Article丨Female Financial Gossip Author: Mu Bai

· · ·

A virtual person with no eyeballs or cornea, and even the action of “blinking” is just a code simulation, said to the camera, “I have been wearing my contact lenses for a day and they are very comfortable.”

The penalty decision of the Guangzhou Panyu District Market Supervision Bureau characterized this line as false advertising and imposed a fine of 68,200 yuan. The amount was not large, but the irony of this incident was extremely high. When Fang Taozi debuted, the most resounding label was “Never Collapse”, but as a result, the first commercial order collapsed because of its incompetence.

In an era when AI replaces everything, we should still be vigilant. What brands spend money to buy is the trust and endorsement of “someone has tried it for you and found it good”, but AI can never give a real user experience.

1./ Why was Fang Taozi punished? /

Fang Taozi’s quotation has caused quite a stir in the industry. It is 168,000 yuan for a video of 1 to 20 seconds, and 258,000 yuan for a video of 60 seconds or more, which is more than a large number of real bloggers with millions or even tens of millions of fans. Why is a virtual character who only debuted for 30 days and has 400,000 fans more expensive than a real person?

At that time, everyone was optimistic that Fang Taozi would “never collapse the house”. Because she has no private life, no emotional outbursts, no drunkenness at three in the morning, no tax evasion. Brands are fed up with the uncontrollable risks of real spokespersons, and virtual humans seem to be the ultimate solution.However, the failure of Fang Taozi’s first single revealed an overlooked paradox. What the brand really wants to obtain from its spokesperson is not only “safety” but also “trustworthiness”.

The real blogger’s price is high because she really wore those contact lenses and blinked her eyes in front of the camera all day long. Fans believe that her feelings are guaranteed by her body. After the AI ​​virtual human eliminates the variable of “physical body”, “safety” is achieved, and “trustworthiness” is also lost. When a brand lets an emotionless character say “it feels very comfortable to wear”, the signal consumers receive is not “this product is good” but “this brand thinks I’m stupid”.

Some netizens questioned, if AI can only say “This is a contact lens with a diameter of 14.2mm and a base arc of 8.6”, then why doesn’t the brand directly put it on the product details page? Spending 250,000 yuan to buy a video is buying a personalized tone of recommendation and a sense of intimacy that says “I tried it for you.” And it is precisely this part that AI is not allowed to provide by law.

Color contact lenses are not ordinary accessories. It belongs to the third category of medical devices, which is the category with the highest risk level. A “Medical Advertising Review Certificate” must be obtained before advertising is released. Fang Taozi’s operator “My Film and Television” does not have this certificate, which is a procedural violation. The more fundamental problem is at the physical level. The Advertising Law requires spokespersons not to recommend or certify unused products, and virtual people can never “use” anything.

AI images can be used for brand display, product introduction, and word-of-mouth selling points, but saying “it’s easy to use in personal testing” and “I feel comfortable using it” is false advertising.Fang Taozi’s sentence, “Because this contact lens has a high-gloss fixed axis, you can blink with confidence,” does not depend on whether the technical description is accurate, but on the fact that the subject who said this did not have the physiological behavior of “blinking” for reference.

The regulatory department’s logical chain of identification is well-founded. The virtual person has no real wearing experience and the virtual person cannot declare subjective feelings. Therefore, it constitutes a fictitious use effect and is determined to be false advertising.

2./ Is it valid for the operator to say that it is “not professional enough”? /

The person in charge of “My Film and Television” admitted in an interview,The team was negligent in operations and lacked professionalism. After discovering the problem, the ads were removed from the shelves and all business cooperation was rejected, with the focus returning to content creation.The attitude is considered sincere, but “not professional enough” obviously underestimates the nature of the problem.

As a team with a background in AI short dramas, its core capabilities are content production and character management. The reason why Fang Taozi was able to attract 400,000 fans in 30 days was because of the heroine with personality and story in “The Girl Who Was Fired”. But the business order submitted by the brand owner is that “this character will tell me how good the product is.” This is no longer separated by lines, but separated by advertising regulations and product liability systems.

It is worth noting that this company has registered 192 copyrights for art works since July this year, and the names of the works are mostly character names. It is manufacturing virtual character assets in batches, and Fang Taozi is just the first one to come out. If subsequent roles copy the same monetization path, each business order will face the same problem. Does this category allow AI to speak? Medical treatment, medicines, medical equipment, health food, the legal requirements for spokespersons are equally stringent for AI.

So “Can AI do advertising?” The analysis of the cover news gives the answer,AI可以客觀展示,不能虛構體驗。Cultural and tourism digital people can explain history, virtual shopping guides can report parameters and dimensions, and government announcers can read announcements. These are “shown” and “conveyed” but are not a guarantee of the product.

The core selling point of cosmetic contact lens advertisements is never just the parameters. The selling point is “does it look good when worn”, “is it comfortable” and “will it dry”. Clothes allow AI to “show” the effects of the upper body, and snacks allow AI to “describe” the taste. Although there is also the risk of marginalization, at least the product itself does not require the spokesperson to have physiological organs.

The advantage of AI endorsement has always been in “efficiency”. There is no need to coordinate schedules, no need to pay long-term endorsement fees, and no hot searches in the middle of the night. But this incident also exposedIt is true that AI humans will never be able to replace humans in some aspects.

About Us · 關於我們