“The escape route for outdated celebrities blocks the way out for ordinary people.”
A few days ago, a sentence“A house that cuts ice does not raise cattle or sheep.”The comments brought host Yang Lan to the forefront.
This sentence comes from the “Book of Rites” and refers to the fact that people who enjoy generous salaries should no longer compete with ordinary people for a meager livelihood.

The cause of the controversy was a live broadcast event conducted by Yang Lan many years ago.
In the eyes of some netizens, ordinary anchors have to work hard to make a living, but celebrities can easily obtain traffic and sky-high fees with their halo. Isn’t this taking away the jobs of ordinary people?
Soon, Yang Lan responded personally, saying that he only tried to bring goods in order to maintain the company’s operations, and he quit the live broadcast industry when the contract expired.
Despite this, the controversy surrounding celebrity sales is far from over.

In this year’s film and television winter, once-famous stars have begun to worry about their next job, and live streaming has become the most crowded track.
It was a real sight for celebrities to bring goods. Some people sold hundreds of millions of dollars in their first show, and some even became famous again through live broadcasts.
However, just six years later, the trend completely reversed.
The “2025 Livestreaming E-commerce Industry Development White Paper” shows that the transaction volume of livestreaming e-commerce in 2025 has exceeded5萬億Yuan, but the reliance on top anchors continues to decline. The cake is getting bigger and bigger, and the celebrity anchors who were once famous are no longer the hot spots that businesses are competing for.

Some media statistics found that the live broadcast pit fees of many celebrities have been declining, and the quotation of a certain star even dropped from 200,000 yuan to 30,000 yuan in one year.
In the past, as long as a celebrity showed up in a live broadcast room, merchants would rush to give away money.
Nowadays, even if you scream your throat out to sell goods, no one may pay.
Celebrity anchors who are accustomed to being admired by many stars finally ushered in the darkest moment when the market brought them back to their original form.

2020: Celebrities with no drama,
Get together live broadcast room
“The destination of stars is to bring goods through live streaming.”
In 2021, Wei Ya, the head anchor who has been banned, once joked at the “Tucao Conference”.
If this sentence were placed in 2019, I am afraid that many people would sneer at it.
That year, Liu Yan tried live streaming for the first time on Kuaishou. Sales exceeded 10 million yuan in 3 hours, but he attracted ridicule of “lowering his status”, “too cheap” and “losing money”.
However, just one year later, live streaming has changed from “shameful” to “really delicious” in the eyes of celebrities.
Some people even think that if a celebrity is not invited to live broadcast to deliver goods, it means that he has become outdated.
2020 can be called the first year of celebrity live streaming.
Liu Tao, Chen He, Wang Han, Zhang Yuqi, Zhang Ting, Hu Haiquan and others have joined the game one after another. Even veteran actors and well-known hosts couldn’t sit still and started live broadcasting for the first time one after another.
According to statistics from Jiemian News, in 2020 there will be at least500位Artists started their first show with goods. On Tmall 618 alone, about 300 celebrities appeared in the live broadcast room.
Why did the trend completely reverse overnight?
The reason is that stars shivering in the cold winter of film and television have hit the e-commerce trend that is gaining momentum.
In 2020, the national movie box office dropped sharply from 64.266 billion yuan in the previous year.20.417 billionYuan. Production crews were suspended and announcements were reduced, leaving many stars without a source of income.
In the e-commerce industry, major platforms are busy competing for live broadcast users, and merchants are also looking forward to using the popularity of celebrities to open up sales.
Celebrities need work, platforms need traffic, businesses need exposure, and the three parties hit it off.
The time and place are favorable, and the battle reports submitted by the stars are more exaggerated than the others, and the records will be refreshed almost every once in a while.
Within 4 hours of Liu Tao’s first live broadcast, the transaction volume reached 148 million yuan. The subsequent three live broadcasts exceeded 100 million yuan, and the fourth one even reached 100 million yuan.2.2億元。
Just four days later, this record was broken again by Zhang Ting. With the help of Tao Hong and others, her first live broadcast transaction volume exceeded2.5億元。
Seeing how profitable the live broadcast room is, more and more celebrities are joining the game, and the routines of the live broadcast room are starting to get complicated.
How hard do celebrities go to sell goods? Being able to speak eloquently is only a basic skill, and you also need to be proficient in eighteen kinds of martial arts.
The various talents in the live broadcast room are simply more comprehensive than the talent show.
Jia Nailiang is known as the “Desperate Saburo”. In the live broadcast room, he sold goods until he knelt down and cried bitterly. He had all the skills in singing and dancing. He performed allegro and fancy rope skipping on the spot, and even tried out lipstick himself.
Others said,“Celebrities who usually have no acting skills have contributed their best acting skills in the live broadcast room.”。
The live broadcast room of Yang Zi and Huang Shengyi once directly staged a business war blockbuster about “the host marked the wrong price”.
During a live broadcast, Yang Zizheng was introducing small kitchen appliances with a package price of 699 yuan. The staff suddenly exclaimed: Why did the operation mark the price to 299 yuan?
After hearing this, the boss got angry on the spot and asked to take it off the shelves, but Yang Zi protected his phone and urged fans to place orders quickly before the boss could react.
After some operations, it seems that consumers are not shopping, but helping the anchor to pick up brand wool.
However, as the old saying in the entertainment industry goes, “When you stand on the wind, even a pig can fly.”
At that time, the reason why the stars who entered the live broadcast market could achieve great results had nothing to do with their professional abilities, but because they encountered the best era of the industry.
After the initial excitement, the false bubbles of celebrity live broadcasts were quickly popped one by one.
2026: From the storm to the minefield,
Just because of the three original sins
It only took a few years for celebrity live broadcasts to turn from a sought-after resource to a hot potato.
In 2020, just as celebrities entered the live broadcast room collectively, a lot of painful lessons emerged at the end of the year that caused businesses to lose their money.
Some merchants said that after signing a 200,000-yuan contract to bring goods to celebrities, they only sold 278 yuan in more than three months, and the two parties even went to court.
The once-famous celebrity live broadcast rooms have also begun to close down one after another.
In 2023, some media re-examined the “Top 30 Celebrity Anchors’ Product Delivery List in 2020” and found that nearly half of the stars have stopped broadcasting, including former celebrity promoters such as Li Xiang, Xie Na, Du Haitao, and Liu Tao.
Why are celebrity live broadcasts suddenly no longer popular? In the final analysis, it is because of its three original sins that it has narrowed its path.
First, it is false propaganda, and selling products relies entirely on acting skills, which overdrafts public trust.
A widely circulated netizen comment expresses what most people feel:
“Celebrities who make tens of millions a year sell products worth 9.9% in their live broadcast rooms. Do you think they can use them themselves?”
This was originally just a reasonable suspicion, but it overturned again and again, turning the doubt into a crisis of confidence.
For example, in 2024, Eric Tsang appeared in the Three Sheep live broadcast room to recommend Meicheng mooncakes and emphasized that they are very good as gifts.
Not long after, Meicheng Mooncakes got into controversy for claiming to be Hong Kong’s high-end mooncakes, and Three Sheep Company was fined for false advertising.
Since celebrities use their reputation as a platform for their products, their personal reputation will inevitably be affected if they fall apart.
What was once the most useful credit endorsement has now become a target of suspicion among consumers.
Second, his professional skills are too poor, he has a celebrity aura, but he is a layman when it comes to products.
Yang Lan talked about the experience of carrying goods a few years ago and sighed: “Every line is like a mountain, and carrying goods is a professional skill.”
However, many celebrity anchors still fail to understand such a simple truth.
In today’s live broadcast industry, which has become a red ocean, professional anchors must not only be eloquent, but also understand product selection, price, supply chain and after-sales.
However, there are quite a few celebrities who want to make money but don’t want to lose their stature. They only serve as a “human background board” in the live broadcast room. They don’t know anything about product information and leave everything to the professional anchors around them.
At first, the brand was willing to pay for fame, but after a while, it was discovered that fans are not equal to customers, and the popularity of live broadcasts is not equal to actual sales.
If you can’t speak with true ability, no matter how great your halo is, it won’t be able to withstand consumption.
Third, they earn high premiums but do not want to take responsibility.
Pan Changjiang once advised actor Xie Mengwei, who was selling fake goods, and reminded him that selling goods on live broadcasts is very deep and not to get involved easily. Unexpectedly, he himself joined the army of carrying goods.
This past incident was nicknamed by netizens as the “Panga acquaintance” and even spawned a popular meme:Those who persuade Ga will eventually become Ga.
Why is this contrast so off-putting? Because of live streaming, it is no longer an industry where everyone can easily make money.
As of the end of May 2025, a total of nearly 1,000 live broadcast and short video anchor accounts have been opened nationwide.193 millionThere are about 33.27 million monthly active broadcast accounts, which is enough to reflect the fierce competition in the industry.
Ordinary anchors must research products for a long time and accumulate reputation before they can get a place. And some celebrities can take off with their fame as soon as they enter the scene.
If you just want to make money while lying down, but you are unwilling to show the professional ability and sense of responsibility that match it, it will certainly attract criticism.
Celebrities can seize the starting line based on their fame, but they cannot ask the market to pay for fame forever.
It’s a good time to make money by relying on traffic,
快到頭了
Some people may question: Nowadays, many celebrity live broadcast rooms still have huge traffic and sell hundreds of millions at every turn. How can we say that celebrities can no longer bring goods?
But in Brother Dao’s view, the business where traffic is king is becoming a thing of the past. Because the rules of the game for live streaming e-commerce have long since changed.
The “2025 Live E-commerce Industry Development White Paper” shows that in 2025, live e-commerce brand store broadcasts will contribute more than 50% of the transaction volume, but the proportion of head anchors has dropped to 10.66%.
what does that mean? The once most popular head anchor is no longer so irreplaceable.
In recent years, the reputation of leading e-commerce anchors has frequently overturned.
For example, Li Jiaqi was criticized for the eyebrow pencil incident and became a hot topic, and finally apologized overnight.
Simba and Xiao Yang both received huge fines for false publicity. Wei Ya, the former top e-commerce lady, was completely banned due to tax issues.
Although the reasons for the collapse are different, they all illustrate one thing: traffic can amplify the commercial value of the anchor, and it can also amplify the risks.
Because of this, many businesses are reducing their reliance on top anchors and instead taking brands and channels into their own hands. And celebrity anchors who only have traffic advantages have become abandoned objects.
When consumers no longer superstitiously trust the recommendations of anchors, brands begin to recalculate input and output, and supervision continues to increase. The e-commerce industry has finally entered the stage of fighting for its true capabilities.
In my opinion, bringing goods by celebrities is not necessarily the same as cutting leeks. Live broadcasting is a legitimate business. The key is whether you have the ability to make a living.
For example, Jia Nailiang, known as the “Big Brother of Celebrity Live Broadcasting”, during this year’s Double 11, his single-day sales exceeded 570 million yuan, setting a personal high in the past three years.
But this achievement is achieved by relying on the professional ability as a goods anchor, not by relying on the star’s halo.
According to media reports, he has been live broadcasting for three consecutive days, with a total duration of more than 30 hours, and the average live broadcast time per game is more than 10 hours, which is almost twice that of the same period last year.
Not only that, he also has a mature operations team behind him. From brand cooperation, product selection and scheduling to live broadcast rhythm, there is a complete set of business system support.
Therefore, in Brother Dao’s view, if a celebrity wants to stay in the live broadcast room, he must do at least two things well.
First of all, let go of the celebrity airs and show your professional skills.
Since you choose to transform into a live broadcast e-commerce, you cannot just regard yourself as a money-collecting platform. The selection of products must be personally checked, and the products must be tried out in person. Publicity cannot be full of lies, let alone push the responsibility to the merchant if something goes wrong.
Secondly, say goodbye to traffic thinking and learn to do long-term business.
Live streaming is not a one-time deal. You can’t just focus on the number of billions sold in one sale, but also look at the return rate, repurchase rate and consumer reputation.
Celebrities can rely on fame to attract customers, but they cannot rely on fame to retain customers.
Traffic can determine who gets the upper hand, and professionalism determines who stays at the poker table.
Related Reading
- Depth丨The outcast Huang Renxun, and the trillion-dollar Nvidia that has lost its helmsman2026-11-15
- Original: Wang Jianlin, 72, re-appointed as chairman of Wanda2026-11-15
- The former chairman voluntarily surrendered! With three changes of leadership in four years, how many question marks does Xiamen Bank hide?2026-11-15
- Behind the U.S. grounding: the air traffic control system has been in service for 50 years, and spare parts rely on overseas purchases2026-11-15
- Hesai, Shenghong, and Nvidia reveal the “pricing system” of technology tycoons’ extramarital affairs2026-11-14